We would have heard this 100′s of times and people are fed up with this idea that Holy prophet asws had said this : "Crying for Dead causes Punishment to the Dead"
And so if someone cries for dead, the dead is punished;and this propaganda increases in moharram
so let us see what ayesha had to offer in this regard
we find in Musnad Ahmad bin Hanbal :
Abu bakar says that when rafi’I bin khadeej died, we heard ibn umar that dead is punished when his neighbors cry for him. I came to umra and told him so he replied that Ayesha said that holy prophet asws said this about a jew lady that these people are crying and she is being punished; then Ayesha recited the verse that none will bear the weight of others
[Musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 31, narration 24616]
Sheikh hamza says isnaad is sahih
[Musnad ahmad, takhreej of ahmad shakir and hamza ahmad, vol 17, page -234]
[Musnad ahmad, takhreej of ahmad shakir and hamza ahmad, vol 17, page -234]
We further find
Ibn umar said that Holy Prophet asws said that dead is
punished when his family cries for him; when someone asked this from
Ayesha, she said that he has hallucinated, holy prophet asws said that
people are crying where as he is being punished for his sins
[Musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 84]
Sheikh hamza says isnaad is sahih
[Musnad ahmad, takhreej of ahmad shakir and hamza ahmad, vol 17, page 287]
Sheikh shoaib says isnaad is sahih on condition of sheikhain [musnad ahmad, vol 40, page 347-348, narration 24302 ]
Yet again, we find
Urwa said that once Ayesha told him that o nephew! Ibn umar erred in listening, actually holy prophet asws passed by a grave and he said that he is being punished due to his deeds and his family is crying for him; otherwise by god! None will bear the weight of others
[Musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 178-179, narration 25144]
Sheikh hamza says isnaad sahih
[Musnad ahmad, takhreej of ahmad shakir and hamza ahmad, vol 17, page 390]
Sheikh shoaib says isnaad are sahih, narrators are all thiqa and narrators of sheikhain
[musnad ahmad, takhreej of sheikh shoaib; vol 41, page 181-182 narration 24637]
[musnad ahmad, takhreej of sheikh shoaib; vol 41, page 181-182 narration 24637]
Again we find
Abu bakar said that when rafi’I bin khadeej died, I heard Abdullah bin umar that dead is punished due to weeping of his neighbors. I came to umra and told him about this; he said that Ayesha said that may allah forgive abu abdurrehman, he is not lying but he has forgotten; holy prophet asws passed by grave of a jew lady on which people were crying, so he said that people are crying where as she is being punished
{molvi zafar iqbal says that narration is sahih as per bukhari, muslim and ibn haban}
[musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 210]
No comments:
Post a Comment